It's much more spoken-word than the live/demo versions we know but it's so lovely to hear an official version of this, one of Pulp's finest moments, after so many years.
-- Edited by Eamonn on Wednesday 25th of May 2022 11:01:55 AM
Sounds like a Lockdown home-recording reminds me a bit of "Thinking About The New Millenium...", I dont think the omnichord is still there but it's lovely, all the same. I reckon a Jarv Is... version of this with harp and violin could be majestic.
Sarah I think you might be able to listen on the embedded player in this page, even without a Spotify account: www.audubon.org/birdsong-project (Cuckoo Song is track 36)
Oh my Holy fuck..... this is just such a surprise. Shame its in the Jarvis "talk" style, but its still lovely. WOW !!! Wonder what made him revisit WLL demos for....?
So beautiful. We drove back from the Jarvis exhibition today, listening to Jarvis in shuffle on Spotify and this came up. I had no idea this had been done. Amazing to have it out in the wild after all these *decades*!
Looking at the credits to this song on Spotify and its credited solely to Jarvis. I wonder would that rule the Pulp demo version out of inclusion on any future reissue? Is there a precedent for a Pulp song released that has written only by Jarvis?
I imagine there must have been songs on TIH written by Jarvis and brought to the group to arrange and play (there is a direct quote from another band member suggesting as much in the BBC Radio 1 doc from 1998) - I imagine stuff like TV Movie and A Little Soul may fall into that category. Everybody got credited of course, ultimately.
It's always been the case..
Jarvis has the initial song and bare bones..
The other guy's flesh it out with their instruments and talents..
It's no revelation...
He's been generous in this regard as far as I'm concerned..
Splitting royalties that dar?
I don't think i would if i was that talented...
What about all that "Let's try and create an atmosphere as if we're in the woods and Candida you're the crunchy leaves and Russell, you're the ominous presence..." etc. shiz? Was that way of writing songs a rare occurrence?
It's not surprising, really. Russell didn't get a credit for "Help the Aged". Mark never got credited for his involvement on "Do You Remember The First Time".
Has anyone found anywhere that this album / the track can be purchased and downloaded? I've been keeping an eye on my usual digital stores and the Birdsong Project site, but have only found streaming links so far. Which is all very well, but I'd like a copy to keep! :)
Reckon so. Live at least - but if recording, why stop there when there are so many unrecorded songs with a similar mood and feel? An EP with G's Nursery, Quiet Rev, and others would be a very special thing indeed. All without setting pen to paper.
Imagine: Got To Have Love opens, followed by My Body May Die; when we finally hear Jarvis, after 5 or 6 minutes of music, his first words would be "You thought I could leave you? I could never leave you". Welcome back! (They always did keep us waiting...)
-- Edited by superchob on Wednesday 14th of September 2022 08:52:01 AM
I once covered it at a Pulp covers night with a classically trained singer. She even played glockenspiel. Don't think the crowd knew what to make of it!
Reckon so. Live at least - but if recording, why stop there when there are so many unrecorded songs with a similar mood and feel? An EP with G's Nursery, Quiet Rev, and others would be a very special thing indeed. All without setting pen to paper.
Imagine: Got To Have Love opens, followed by My Body May Die; when we finally hear Jarvis, after 5 or 6 minutes of music, his first words would be "You thought I could leave you? I could never leave you". Welcome back! (They always did keep us waiting...)
This idea is genius!
I'm hopeful that they'll do something a bit different to the 2011/'12 reunion. I'd settle for a shake-up of the festival/hits set to incorporate more of the later material (imagine starting Glastonbury with an opening salvo of Party Hard and After You cranked-up loud) and Jarvis is a bit of a people-pleaser including us uber-phans, so maybe there'll be the odd wonderful surprise.
There's suggestion he played 2 songs at that Birdlife event. I wonder was the other one Birds In Your Garden (thematically similar and very melodic like Cuckoo...maybe it actually bumped Cuckoo off consideration for We Love Life ...and also a good one to play solo on an acoustic guitar).
Can't believe no footage has emerged, it would be great to see.
Still dreaming a new album that would include all the leftovers from TIH (the demos released in 2006) and WLL demos. There's enough material and it would make a great record.
Just have to do it !
I mean, you are the one, street operator, After you (new version, wasn't too keen on the 2012 one), Got To Have Love, Quiet Revolution, Cuckoo song... already got half on a great record. Such a waste.
Or release a WLL box set, dammit.
I sound angry but actually i'm pretty pleased since Jarvis has released a lot of stuff the past months. But we want more, always, right ? :D
Honestly compared to the leaked demo I can't stand it....the way the demo builds up & gets going is so life-affirming. I really don't like it, sorry :(
I just can't help but think a real (Chris Thomas?) version might have been that No1 Jarvis so sought in the day? Sadly a No1 would mean nothing in today's climate