Feels like the Guardian didn't even talk about the songs.
Yeah, it's more about the narrative of the Pulp reformation than the songs themselves, and that feels like a shame to me. Like, these are such carefully crafted instrumentals! That's what really struck me at the listening party: there's so much going on under the bonnet of these songs, and James Ford has given them room to breathe too (I was sceptical of him, I felt Spike Island was a bit over-polished, but I think it's the exception - will need to listen again though)
-- Edited by lipglossed on Monday 2nd of June 2025 04:09:37 PM
Edit: This word-filter is getting out of hand. I understand c0Ck being asterisked but s.hite? C'mon, we're all "Grown-Ups" here...
-- Edited by Eamonn on Monday 2nd of June 2025 03:48:34 PM
And while we're at it, is there any way of adding support for em-dashes, please? I'm constantly using em-dashes and then they don't show up in my posts, so I have to go back and edit them to add hyphens instead otherwise they're unreadable. I love a good em-dash.
Feels like the Guardian didn't even talk about the songs.
Yeah, it's more about the narrative of the Pulp reformation than the songs themselves, and that feels like a shame to me. Like, these are such carefully crafted instrumentals! That's what really struck me at the listening party: there's so much going on under the bonnet of these songs, and James Ford has given them room to breathe too (I was sceptical of him, I felt Spike Island was a bit over-polished, but I think it's the exception - will need to listen again though)
-- Edited by lipglossed on Monday 2nd of June 2025 04:09:37 PM
yeah James Ford is known for really atmospheric symphonic records The Last shadow Puppets records which are amazing, and the Arctic Monkeys later albums that i love, and that Alex turner Submarine EP which should have been a full solo albums and it would have become a classic... and also Blur recently. Since Pulp is going down that route, it was a good choice i think. We'll see at the end of the week !
I agree about the over-polishing though, both Spike Island and GTHL are, but I guess it's a sign of times.
Edit: This word-filter is getting out of hand. I understand c0Ck being asterisked but s.hite? C'mon, we're all "Grown-Ups" here...
-- Edited by Eamonn on Monday 2nd of June 2025 03:48:34 PM
And while we're at it, is there any way of adding support for em-dashes, please? I'm constantly using em-dashes and then they don't show up in my posts, so I have to go back and edit them to add hyphens instead otherwise they're unreadable. I love a good em-dash.
The ****ing profanity filter cannot be disabled for free forums.
If you read the forum guidelines post at the top, Steve has used the word "arse" several times and this isn't censored. Odd!
I just had to google what em-dashes are and can't see any options to add them specifically. Maybe the settings for your keyboard would allow it?
-- Edited by Ian on Monday 2nd of June 2025 05:56:49 PM
Edit: This word-filter is getting out of hand. I understand c0Ck being asterisked but s.hite? C'mon, we're all "Grown-Ups" here...
-- Edited by Eamonn on Monday 2nd of June 2025 03:48:34 PM
And while we're at it, is there any way of adding support for em-dashes, please? I'm constantly using em-dashes and then they don't show up in my posts, so I have to go back and edit them to add hyphens instead otherwise they're unreadable. I love a good em-dash.
The ****ing profanity filter cannot be disabled for free forums.
If you read the forum guidelines post at the top, Steve has used the word "arse" several times and this isn't censored. Odd!
I just had to google what em-dashes are and can't see any options to add them specifically. Maybe the settings for your keyboard would allow it?
-- Edited by Ian on Monday 2nd of June 2025 05:56:49 PM
That's because it's a Canadian Company, Arse means nothing there. How about ass, let's see, or ASS.
Edit: that works too
-- Edited by andy on Monday 2nd of June 2025 06:24:39 PM
-- Edited by andy on Monday 2nd of June 2025 06:24:54 PM
But this seems to be a recent thing. Jarvis ****er hasn't been sanitised this much since the Master of the Universe single...
Just a hunch, it may be because Steve logged in again recently for the first time in years and tweaked a few things. Some sort of update may have occurred.
Oddly, profanities are displayed in all their glory on the preview. The filter must only be applied when someone actually posts.
Weakest review to date, here...what a lyric from My Sex if true! (to rival "a Teddy bear with an erection" on Leftovers before he decided to replace it...):
Some beautiful parts in the New Yorker interview/chat especially the story about Jarvis' Mum's ex-partner who brought Jarvis' first guitar... no point linking it as the link will break cos of the profanity in his surname but it's well-worth a read...
"Slow Jam" and "My Sex" are dreadful, and therefore "Farmers Market" suffers by being stuck in the middle of them, like a rose between two overgrown thorns, and you start to wonder if they should have bothered coming back at all."
While Brooklyn Vegan be like:
"... "Slow Jam" and "My Sex" offer lush, deep-shag funk with Barry White-inspired sexy whispering, making for arguably the two best songs on the album."
That's the last time Jarvis uses that paper to name his band...
(Un-paywalled below):
Jarvis ****er lacks his usual élan in Pulps comeback album More review The Sheffield band return with their first record in 24 years, but the 11 songs lack chemistry
Ludovic Hunter-Tilney
At last the Son of God has turned up in a Pulp song. He got a shout-out of sorts in their 1998 album This Is Hardcore, when Jarvis ****er sang: I am not Jesus, though I have the same initials. But now, as the Sheffield band release their first album in 24 years, the other JC turns up in person.
He appears in the song Slow Jam, commiserating with Jarvis about a failing relationship. Jesus said, I feel your pain, the singer intones. The Messiah doesnt have much more to offer than that, and Jarvis whose voice has got lower and thicker over time isnt on top form either. The songs juxtaposition of religion and sex has a Leonard Cohen-esque slant, but the lyrics lack the singers usual élan. The encounter between the two JCs proves a damp squib.
So, alas, does Pulps comeback album. More was inspired by the band debuting a new song called Hymn of the North while touring the reunion circuit. According to ****er: That seemed to open the floodgates. It was recorded in just three weeks. Despite this rapid dispatch, the results have a laborious feel, as though pushed and prodded into workable shape.
More is dedicated to bassist Steve Mackey, who died in 2023, just before the start of the bands reunion tour. Original guitarist Russell Senior is absent. ****er is joined by drummer Nick Banks, keyboardist Candida Doyle and guitarist Mark Webber. This cobbled-together set-up is supplemented by other hands. A couple of tracks, including Slow Jam, were developed by ****ers band Jarv Is, whose violinist Emma Smith and bassist Andrew McKinney have also transferred over. Lead single Spike Island, one of the better efforts, was composed by Jason Buckle of ****er-affiliated outfit, All Seeing I.
The 11 songs share themes but lack chemistry. Grown Ups tackles ageing, a frequent topic in ****ers writing, but its ill-served by haphazard shifts in lyrical focus and a dated indie chug. Got to Have Love is a thin disco-rock anthem in which Britpops smartest lyricist limits himself to the trite observation that love is all. Hymn of the North is an overcooked orchestral number that cant decide whether northern England is somewhere to leave or return to. A Sunset, co-written by Richard Hawley, layers on the sentimentality so tweely as to resemble a childrens song. I wish I could say otherwise, but Pulps second coming is a disappointment.
That was by far the worst but almost all reviews have been positive.
That dude is also overly-fixated on the lyrics and to say that there being four original members means the group is cobbled-together is disrespectful. Senior left in '97 and Steve died - what exactly are they meant to do about that?!
Ah, look at what that review says about HOTN and pay no heed. It's not a bit overcooked and I don't agree that it leaves you wondering whether the North is a place to leave or return to. Part of what I love is how affectionate it sounds towards the North. The song reminds me of Russell saying he felt this great pride that he came from somewhere so unremittingly ugly (his words, folks, not mine!). I have never been to the North of England so I can't say! But I do know you can love a place despite all of the hardships it might have foisted upon you and all of the prejudice you may face because you're from that place. Everyone's entitled to an opinion so I'm entitled to say I think that's a load of rubbish, that review. I keep saying it, I think that's my favourite ever pulp song now. So warm, so soulful.
I've just realised that the listening party I went to played the second side first! I'm now forever going to expect My Sex to be the first song!!! To be honest I think I prefer the listening order I heard it in. Second side is stronger in my opinion or at least on first listen.
The NY article you posted, Eamonn was great, thank you. Found that amazing about the man who gave him the guitar when he was a child. So glad he tracked him down and had those moments. Like it was meant to be.
-- Edited by Jean on Tuesday 3rd of June 2025 07:21:57 PM
-- Edited by Jean on Tuesday 3rd of June 2025 07:23:23 PM
As a song like Hymn Of The North spirals heavenward, bandmates and collaborators give his voice a resonance that it hasn't had since that last Pulp album. They understand who they are and what they do. On More, I hear Pulp embracing their own greatness. After all these years, they've tapped right back into all the beautiful, ineffable things about Pulp - the sneaky insights, the charged-up banter, the lux atmosphere, the anthemic scope, the emotional weight that comes through even when they try to disguise it with cleverness. Once again, a legendary band has returned to us with another miracle.
The Wall Street Journal know their stuff better than the Financial Times:
More by Pulp Review: Satire and Sincerity The Britpop bands first studio album in 24 years offers a hopeless yet humorous perspective on life today. By Mark Richardson June 3, 2025 4:50 pm ET Pulp
In the 1990s, the U.K. was in thrall to Britpop, the retro-leaning movement that was a more melodic answer to the grunge that had taken hold in the U.S. Among the biggest bands of the scene, Oasis had anthems, Blur had taste and Pulp had style. That last, Sheffield-based band, led by singer Jarvis ****er, was initially an outlier because its first two albums came out in the 80s and werent representative of what came later. But by 1994s His n Hers, Pulp had mastered its own brand of multifaceted guitar pop, which mixed glam rock, disco and punk. Mr. ****er, whose persona was a magnetic fusion of Bryan Ferrys louche sexiness and Elvis Costellos wit, became one of rocks great frontmen. And then, after Pulps 2001 album We Love Life, produced by avant-pop legend Scott Walker, the group went its separate ways.
The bands membership had always been fluid, though drummer Nick Banks and keyboardist Candida Doyle were there from nearly the beginning, and it was fair to assume after it split that Mr. ****er would pick up where the band left off. But he had tired of Pulps celebrity and pursued low-key solo projects. In what has become an increasingly common progression for once-disbanded groups, a series of reunion tours led to studio sessions and now, after 24 years, we have a new Pulp record.
The stunningly strong More (Rough Trade), out Friday, is a celebration of everything that made it great in the first place. The opening Spike Island is both heavy and slinky, marrying a quasi-disco beat to a palpitating bassline thats at once sensual and menacing. Mr. ****er, a bundle of jittery energy, spits out his lines as if hes walking briskly on the street next to you and trying to finish his story before heading down into the tube. Hes an exceptionally good lyricist with an uncanny ability to mix satire and sincerity, and here he jokes about the absurdity of making a life in music while nodding to his bands history and extended absence: Not a shaman or a showman / Ashamed I was selling the rights / I took a breather / And decided not to ruin my life.
During his mellower solo years, Mr. ****er has acquired some wisdom but has lost none of his mischievousness. Much of More is about looking for love and breaking up, though nothing is ever simple. On the second track, Tina, his narrator thinks hes found the perfect relationship, but hes never met his obsession and she doesnt know he exists: An outside observer would call him a deranged stalker. Mr. ****er has an eye for telling imageshere he imagines making love in a charity shops storage room, The smell of digestive biscuits in the air. The singer delivers that amusing and pathetic track over a grand orchestral production with strings and a choir, which lends pathos to his wry observations, and the lush production throughout by James Ford (Arctic Monkeys, Blur) adds drama.
Grown Ups is a pulsing rock number that ticks like a time bomb and then explodes. Slow Jam, which finds Mr. ****er conversing with Jesus and learning that hes tired of hearing about the ills of the world, is built around a funky and hypnotic bassline that captures the R&B atmosphere suggested by its title. The Hymn of the North, a stirring and stately ballad about the impossibility of enduring happiness, has a Wagnerian grandeur. And My Sex, in which Mr. ****er pokes fun at his own Lothario image, is a sleazy midtempo rock number with sustained guitars and Gregorian chant-style backing vocals.
As strong as the music isthese songs are as catchy and memorable as those from Pulps mid-90s peakMr. ****ers lyrics stay with you even more. On Background Noise, a searing psychedelic ballad with a knockout chorus, he sings of the difficulty of appreciating love in the moment, concluding that Like the buzzing of a fridge / You only notice when it disappears. And on the closing A Sunset, he sees a world where the tenderest human emotion is merely fodder for advertising, interpolating a famous soft-drink jingleone person sees a beautiful sunset, another is thinking of how to profit from it.
The singer is consumed with anger and disgusted by the world, its superficiality and the way the powerful rule over the powerless, and yet his observations are delivered with warmth and he knows that the best way to cope is to have a good laugh. That after all this time he and his band are able to render these feelings so clearly in indelible pop songs is inspiring.
Les inrocks from what was posted earlier, just the first page not a review, review isnt on their website either. it's a paywall
Left Page (green background text): I much prefer the imaginary to reality More, A long-awaited return to rediscover the unique charm of the former Pulp frontman, who is now celebrating 30 years in the business. Before a French tour and a date at La Route du Rock on August 15, we met with the singer and co-founder of the legendary Britpop band, Jarvis ****er, as well as Mark Webber, guitarist for the Sheffield-based group.
Right Page (with the band photo): DOSSIER In January 2023, the band Pulp announced a highly anticipated reunion tour across Europe. For fans, it was a long-awaited moment, especially since the group hadn't released a new album since We Love Life in 2001. Known for their wry lyrics, social commentary, and Jarvis ****ers unique stage presence, Pulp became one of the defining bands of the Britpop era, alongside Blur and Oasis. Tension and fine teeth In the mid-90s, their music narrated the reality of British youth with rare intensity and humor. A portrait of a generation clever, cheeky, and unforgettable.