Yeah, I was just curious if you thought as a whole, Pulp were still being inventive and arty in 1997 but they "bottled it" a little with the eventual album they handed over.
Nice reference to Butterfly by Weezer. I love TV Movie as it is (it needs the sad keys and the measured lead guitar to progress the song imo) but Pinkerton is a great album, their own This Is Hardcore/difficult post-success follow-up album, (a theme I wanged-on about in the TIH playback thread).
I do try with This Is Hardcore periodically, but how I feel about it never really changes. There are plenty of things to admire about it - the ambition (in places), the honesty (in places), some good songs, some exciting musical moments. But too often, for me there's just not enough of a strike rate on any of those things overall. And like Weej, it's Pulp record that's furthest away from my personal tastes, which isn't its fault.
I also don't think it quite delivers what it promises on the 'weird difficult arty' angle. Bar a couple of tracks, it's a pretty straight pop/rock album - probably as straight at Pulp get, really.
-- Edited by Sturdy on Thursday 5th of December 2024 04:13:08 PM
__________________
"Yes I saw her in the chip shop / so I said get yer top off"