Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Bar Italia Forum -> Bar Italia Forum -> RateYourMusic.com
Post Info TOPIC: RateYourMusic.com
Stephen


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 2300
Date:
RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

The excellent website rateyourmusic.com allows users to give records marks out of 5. Because it's used by so many people, it's quite interesting to see what trends show. Also, each record - if it's good enough in the eyes of the readers - either gets put into a chart of the best of that year, and also the best overall. Here's how Pulp have done. I look forward to this provoking some discussion!

1. Different Class
Obviously. DC averages 4.03 out of 5 and came 4th for its year of release in 1995 (behind Radiohead, GZA and "Death"!). It was 236th overall.

2. His 'n' Hers
Likely to cause ructions on here, HnH scores a 3.91 and came 31st for its year (1207th overall). Second best? Hmm...contentious!

3. This is Hardcore
3.87 out of 5, so only just below HnH, TIH came 38th for its year, but far lower than HnH overall at being only the official 1630th best album ever.

4. Pulpintro
3.75 out of 5 is still pretty good, and it came 107th for its year (2817th overall).

5. We Love Life
Just sneaking into the top five, WLL scores 3.61 and came 270th for its year. It was not on the overall chart.

6. Jarvis (by Jarvis)
Solo album time as J by J scores 3.43 and gets to being 830th best album for the year it was released. That's pretty low.

7. Separations
There must be some 'haters' as 'Seppy' only scores 3.34, and comes 640th for 1992.

8. A Heavy Nite With...
Jarvis, Richard and Wayne get a 3.31, so only slightly behind Separations. This does not feature in the top 1,000 for its year of release.

9. Further Complications
I take umbrage at this as I do really like this album, but it only scores 3.21.

10. Freaks
Further disappointments here as Freaks only notches up a 3.19. It is, however, the 682nd best album of that year though, apparently!

11. It
3.03 ain't that bad for an album no-one seems to love, and it comes 811st for its year.



__________________

swaying slightly, drunk on the sun, I suppose
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

811th surely.

Liquid Swords by GZA (pronounced Jizza - no really) is a great album no doubt (considered by some to be one of the greatest rap albums ever - well, certainly in the last 40 years...) but better than Different Class... no.

How does the scoring work?

If only one person voted for an album but gave it five would that end up high in the chart because it has a perfect score?

If an album gets more votes does that mean it gets higher in the charts assuming they're not bad scores being given?

What's number one of all time?

__________________
Stephen


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 2300
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

811th, yes.

Jizza. Sounds like one of your topic headers.

You give it a mark out of 5. It takes an average.

Fred, albums only enter the charts when they have a certain number of votes. I think it's around 30 or 40.

An album with 1,000 votes and a score of 3.68 will be below an album with 500 votes and a score of 3.69 as far as I'm aware.

OK Computer I think.

__________________

swaying slightly, drunk on the sun, I suppose
Fran


Legendary

Status: Offline
Posts: 1004
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Can't we stick with the Bilbo Baggins style eighty-one-ty first??



__________________

We'll use the one thing we've got more of, that's our minds.
saw119


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 1775
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

I always preferred Only Built 4 Cuban Linx by Raekwon The Chef myself.

__________________

Where Pigeons go to die.
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Check you out!

Did you google that or are you a genuine fan?

__________________
saw119


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 1775
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

No, I am a genuine fan! It was the first Wu Tang album I bought back in '95.

__________________

Where Pigeons go to die.
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Oh yeah you liked that Viktor Vaughn track I put on the producers thread didn't you? I can heartily recommend the album it came from: Vaudeville Villain.

__________________
Eamonn


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 4715
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

There was rap more than forty years ago?

__________________

Tell mester to f*ck off!
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

That was just a bit of fun. Like when magazines run polls of the best films of all time - but they're all from the last hundred years. Obviously.

__________________
Fran


Legendary

Status: Offline
Posts: 1004
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

I always find the NME lists are usually full of Pulp-love these days, here's another in this week's mag:

http://www.nme.com/news/various-artists/64427

This comes after being #1 song of the 90s and best thing at Coachella.



__________________

We'll use the one thing we've got more of, that's our minds.
Stephen


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 2300
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Maybe someone should point out certain old NME reviews of Pulp material...

__________________

swaying slightly, drunk on the sun, I suppose
Jazza


Someone Like The Moon

Status: Offline
Posts: 891
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

yes, but they did put The Beach Boys 4th which somewhat undermines Pulp's position

__________________

I'm not Jesus, though I have the same initials

mixcloud.com/jasminelightfoot/
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Does it? Do you hate The Beach Boys?

__________________
Stephen


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 2300
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Jesus Christ, that's a bad list. Does anyone else find it odd btw that Ian Curtis' violent racist antics get brushed under the carpet, yet if any artist did similar (or, in Morrissey's case, they *decide* he's said similar) they get vilified? Odd.

That list looks like a Shine Comp gone wrong. So stodgy and dull. I mean...I *like* Good Vibrations, but it's hardly up *there* - certainly it's no God Only Knows. Likewise the Bowie choice. I think it's far from his best. And then all that dull, listless crap like Stone Roses and Oasis. Not a Smiths fan either, but I suppose I can see it's a decent song.

Mind you, I still remember Melody Maker declaring "Sgt. Pepper" to be the worst album of all time. "Of all time?" I thought, "Really?" In a world with a third Spice Girls album, a second Menswear album...Steps...oh dear...all this reminds me why I stopped reading the weeklies!


__________________

swaying slightly, drunk on the sun, I suppose
Stephen


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 2300
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Fred...I can see Jazza's point. I like the Beach Boys to an extent, but they really do lack the bite that makes music brilliant - to my ears. That said, I think God Only Knows is a beautiful song...but even then, I must confess that I prefer Bowie's early 80s version of same!

__________________

swaying slightly, drunk on the sun, I suppose
Jazza


Someone Like The Moon

Status: Offline
Posts: 891
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

The song is listenable and certainly above a lot of the crap on the radio now but it's hardly the forth best of all time

__________________

I'm not Jesus, though I have the same initials

mixcloud.com/jasminelightfoot/
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Fair enough. I wouldn't have placed it there either but I do like the song.

__________________
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

It's refreshing that The Beatles aren't number one but it seems bizarre that they're so low.

__________________
Stephen


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 2300
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

I'd trust RateYourMusic more than the NME. And also, where NME says "Greatest songs" it means, with the exception of Day in the Life, "Greatest singles"

And here's RYM's "Greatest Singles". I still disagree with some of these, but they have been voted by more people, and it's nice to see Velvets, Lou Reed, 'Dock of the Bay' and similar on there at least. And Love, who so often get ignored.

1 The Beach Boys Wouldn't It Be Nice / God Only Knows
2 The Beatles Penny Lane / Strawberry Fields Forever
3 David Bowie Life on Mars? / The Man Who Sold the World
4 The Smiths There Is a Light That Never Goes Out
5 Joy Division Love Will Tear Us Apart / These Days
6 Joy Division Atmosphere / She's Lost Control
7 The Beach Boys Good Vibrations
8 Jimi Hendrix Voodoo Chile (Slight Return) / Hey Joe / All Along the Watchtower
9 Bob Dylan Like a Rolling Stone
10 David Bowie "Heroes"
11 Otis Redding (Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay
12 The Smiths How Soon Is Now?
13 Lou Reed Walk on the Wild Side / Perfect Day
14 The Velvet Underground Sunday Morning / Femme Fatale
15 The Rolling Stones Paint It, Black
16 Sam Cooke Shake
17 The Ronettes Be My Baby
18 Television Marquee Moon
19 Kate Bush Running Up That Hill
20 Love Alone Again Or

__________________

swaying slightly, drunk on the sun, I suppose
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Be My Baby on both lists? Coincidence? Is it even the best Motown type song? I prefer Nowhere to Run.

__________________
yankeehotelfoxtrot


Hardcore

Status: Offline
Posts: 169
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Nice to see Low so high in 1994. Might not have mentioned it but I like Low.

__________________

Every drop in the ocean counts.
Stephen


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 2300
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

There's a couple on both lists, Fred. I do adore Be My Baby. But I'm gonna be awkward and say my favourite version is a John Lennon version from the mid 70s. Drunk and pleading for his 'baby' with a full, shambolic Wall of Sound as produced by an out of control Phil Spector. Bombastic, desperate and heartfelt. Highly recommended!

__________________

swaying slightly, drunk on the sun, I suppose
fredthe3rd


200% and Bloody Thirsty

Status: Offline
Posts: 1420
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

That does sound quite appealing. My point though was that I didn't think it was THAT well known a song. Yeah I know everyone knows it, can't explain myself very well... Hopefully you get what I mean.

__________________
Eamonn


The Only Way is Down

Status: Offline
Posts: 4715
Date:
RE: RateYourMusic.com
Permalink  
 

Stephen wrote:

Maybe someone should point out certain old NME reviews of Pulp material...

 

Different journalists, different opinions. Thank God. Which makes these polls pretty silly but they're harmless if taken as fun. Who could ever agree on the best song of the last 60 years, never mind a list of them?

I do wonder though, how often journalists reviewing albums for music publications get their editors reminding them that one of the big record labels have paid for a full page advertising said new album and wouldn't it be nice if a quote from your review was on it so even if it's shit pretend it isn't.



__________________

Tell mester to f*ck off!
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
Bar Italia Forum -> Bar Italia Forum -> RateYourMusic.com
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard