If Pulp wants to move forward, there must be more than just these nostalgia shows. Devotion is needed. You cannot record an album with one member being half-in the band. The realisation of these 2012 shows without Russell show, to me, the others in the band have the willingness to go on with the band even without Russell. If Russell would have said: "I'll be back in 2013", the others would have waited I guess.
Jarvis is a songwriter and he will record songs either with or without Pulp and it seems to me that taking this Pulp2011 thing to the next year that there will be more than just concerts. Perhaps not this year, maybe next.
I suspect the most likely scenario is Jarvis recording a third solo album, but continuing touring with Pulp. The problem with another Pulp album is that unless it is Different Class MkII, it will be widely ignored. Whereas a solo album doesn't have any baggage.
Pulp will continue in their current form for a good while yet. There are other comment regarding how London-centric the reunion has been so far, so I suspect a few dates around Albion are due.
They've played in London more than anywhere since the reunion. It'd be nice for a band with strong ties to the North to play somewhere other than Leeds festival. And they ended their career last time in Rotherham, so why shouldn't they do something similar again?
Arguably, they are a London band...
(cue massive disagreement)
What I mean by that is Pulp 1989-present was formed by the experience of London. Different Class is as valid a document of London as a Kinks, a Blur or even a Madness album. The Beatles are also more of a London band as well. And Oasis
All that said, a Pulp gig in the north is overdue. We have been spoiled down here with Hyde Park, Brixton and now the Albert Hall. My only fear is that the next Pulp gig in London will be the O2.
I think someone needs to take a trip to that pub in Leyland and ask the landlord for an update.
Say what now?
Remember that recent thread where a poster on here was drinking in a pub a few weeks back, got chatting to the owner who turned out to be from Sheffield and claimed that Pulp were recording new stuff.
They've played in London more than anywhere since the reunion. It'd be nice for a band with strong ties to the North to play somewhere other than Leeds festival. And they ended their career last time in Rotherham, so why shouldn't they do something similar again?
Arguably, they are a London band...
(cue massive disagreement)
What I mean by that is Pulp 1989-present was formed by the experience of London. Different Class is as valid a document of London as a Kinks, a Blur or even a Madness album. The Beatles are also more of a London band as well. And Oasis
All that said, a Pulp gig in the north is overdue. We have been spoiled down here with Hyde Park, Brixton and now the Albert Hall. My only fear is that the next Pulp gig in London will be the O2.
That was my point exactly when I suggested that they didn't need some massive send off in Sheffield. It would be nice but why would they do it?
That was my point exactly when I suggested that they didn't need some massive send off in Sheffield. It would be nice but why would they do it?
Down the years with a few exceptions (notably Glastonbury & Auto), the higher profile Pulp gigs have been in London, going right back to the Christmas shows at The Garage and Theatre Royal through to Finsbury Park and onto last year's dates at Brixton and Hyde Park. And now the Royal Albert Hall.
Unlike the Stone Roses who are indelibly linked with Manchester and for whom there was nowhere else they could have made their big comeback, Pulp are as much identified with London as Sheffield.
All that said, they should play a gig or two outside London.
Obviously there's a strong London connection but considering the band rehearsed last year in Sheffield, some of the band still live there and Jarvis spends a lot of time there, you can't say they're not bothered about the place!
Remember that recent thread where a poster on here was drinking in a pub a few weeks back, got chatting to the owner who turned out to be from Sheffield and claimed that Pulp were recording new stuff.
Rings a bell. Honestly my long-term (and short-term and medium-term) memory is shot to shit.
I wouldn't mind so much if I'd done drugs or something to cause it but I'm pretty square.
Obviously there's a strong London connection but considering the band rehearsed last year in Sheffield, some of the band still live there and Jarvis spends a lot of time there, you can't say they're not bothered about the place!
I think the whole rehearsing in Sheffield thing was due to Russell more than anything else. I don't think Jarvis spends that much time up here in Sheffield.
I think someone needs to take a trip to that pub in Leyland and ask the landlord for an update.
Say what now?
Remember that recent thread where a poster on here was drinking in a pub a few weeks back, got chatting to the owner who turned out to be from Sheffield and claimed that Pulp were recording new stuff.
Our memories were all forcibly wiped.
Don't speak of it, you don't know what horrors await you.
Is that the recent trixy/dixy thread (I get them mixed up), I remember seeing the deleted post and thinking I hadn't read it, but it does ring a bell now.
I know it wasn't worded how I said, and I can see people's points, but I'll be pretty annoyed and surprised if the UK part of the reunion amounted to loads of gigs in London and nothing bar one festival date up north. Just doesn't seem very Pulp to me. I was proved right about them returning to Glasto and I reckon I'll be right again!
I think they'll finish off this year of touring with a couple of big gigs, definitely including one in Yorkshire. This is what Jarvis said would happen in a Q&A last year- I think they've just taken the opportunity to play more festivals/tour America just because they could, cos they enjoyed last year so much. I don't think they're going to drag the reunion out past 2012.
We already know that Jarvis has been doing more recording by himself, due to that NME blog where the girl had played kazoo on a song. So I'm sure we'll get a third album at some point. There will never be another Pulp album.