This has been covered before but not with A POLL! (I think)
So which is your favourite?
Glory Days or Cocaine Socialism?
And if the question on the tip of your tongue is 'which version of Cocaine Socialism?' - the answer would be your favourite version of Cocaine verses the album version of Glory Days.
Ah yes, that does ring a bell! I'd quite forgotten about that.
I generally preferred Cocaine Socialism's lyrics (and it would have made one hell of a brave single), but Glory Days felt so anthemic, and was a rare live highlight in the '98 days.
Two really different songs, yet they both have their own quality:
Cocaine Socialism I used to not really like political songs when i was younger, and i still dont (Erm, Cunts Running The World, now that's a shit song), because to me they're usually a way to get bigger faster & easier, when you're a band. And most of the time they dont turn out too good, like pagent winners wanting peace on earth, okay, great. that's why i love Pulp because they managed to stay out of this formula, but in the meantime make some really good social commentaries on our society.
So when it was released as cocaine socialism i didnt really care for it, now i gotta say i enjoy it: the lyrics are smart, the music is agressive enough. Still i can see why it couldnt be on TIH. Looking back on it i think it could have been "THE" Pulp tune if released as a single, because of the lyrical content. But the controversy would probably have overshadowed their entire career.
Glory Days I love this version simply because it speaks much more to me, especially the line "I could be a genius if I just put my mind to it" which is pure... genius. It's an overall theme that a lot of people can relate to, more so than Cocaine Socialism i guess. And it's much more universal than Common People, which is really an english song. Glory Days is the Common People for the rest of the world. It's hard to express with words when english isn't your native language, but there you go, it speaks to me, to my bones, head, heart, skin. Something that is right.
Yeah, Pulp were so keen to rush release 'Common People' because they knew it would be huge. But similarly, 'Cocaine Socialism' would also have been enormous. And yet they stepped back from it. Shame really. It would have given them that second wind that they never really experience.
Even as a B Side it still got them more press than than the A Side seemed to manage!
"If there is anyone who could salvage Tony Blair's dreams of "Cool Britannia" - and win his government the respect among young people that he seems to crave - it must be Jarvis. So the news this week that he and his band Pulp have released a song entitled Cocaine Socialism will have been met with sickly smiles and queasy stomachs in Downing Street."
"Cocaine Socialism (Island records) by Pulp is the B-side to the single, A Little Soul."
This is definitely one for http://www.alternatehistory.com/
Maybe even Russell could have been enthused into returning had the single come out. Is he on the finished version at all, do we know...? Or is he mixed out, like on Help the Aged...?
I think Russell appears on the demo (TIH deluxe version) of Cocaine Socialism but not the released version.
I can see why Jarvis didn't have the stomach for it. He was in the midst of a nervous breakdown and the tune is very close to Common People (hence 'Glory People' being played live...was the full Glory Days ever performed? It would be nice to hear a live rendition of the modulation in the last verse. Every version that's out there such as The Park Is Mine segues into Common People at that point).
It would have been a hit but anything Pulp released in 1997 would have been a hit such was their stock. (equally, I think We Can Dance Again is a the missing bridge between The Sisters EP and Common People and would have been a big hit at the turn of '94/95. But, likewise, I think in hindsight it would have felt weak, a bit of a pastiche).
There's no doubt over the prescience of the song matter at the time but the lyrics feel a bit dated now. Maybe the musical similarity to CP was the whole point, chiming with the ''Well you sing about Common People and the misshapes and the misfits'' line.
Ultimately though, while a tad over-produced, I prefer Glory Days. The lyrics are just as good (arguably one of the strongest Pulp lyrics for fantastic couplets and one-liners), but not tied to a particular time and as Andy said, a lot more universal.
Ah, the demo being the one with more backing vocals and horns? Interesting. I'd not noticed any different guitar parts.
I don't think CS is *that* similar to Common People, but perhaps someone who knows more about music can dissaude me!
I also agree re: We Can Dance Again. I remember first hearing it (in North Wales on holiday last year for my birthday!) and thinking the intro sounding amazing...but the rest of it didn't live up to that wonderful beginning. Like Lazarus by the Boo Radleys :)
Glory Days will 'live on' for longer lyrically I think, but there's a lot of good political/of their time songs that do still survive. For example, I think that people are able to get through listening to the line in the Beatles' "Good Morning, Good Morning" about "it's time for tea and 'Meet the Wife'" without being aware of the Thora Hird sitcom it was referring to.
Am I suggesting New Labour was a sitcom? Well....!
Cocaine Socialism and Common People have similar chords, not exactly the same, but i wouldn't call the two songs similar. They're Pulp songs, so there's a definite link, but that's about it. When you make a song with C F G in it it's bound to be alike anyway.
Built on the same chords (until it changes key for the ''These glory days can take their toll''bit), similar tempo and similar vocal melody at times. Jarvis has admitted as much.
While I love "Glory Days" for its elegaic, universal quality, I have to give the edge to "Cocaine Socialism," just because you can really hear the venom in that song. There's something really immediate about it. Also, I don't think it's quite as dated as you might think.
"When you said "I want to see you To discuss your contribution / To the future of our nation's heart and soul Six o'clock, my place, Whitehall" / Well I arrived just after seven But you said "It doesn't matter" / "I understand your situation And your image, and I'm flattered / Oh and I'd just like to tell you That I love all of your albums / Could you sign this for my daughter? She's in hospital, her name is Miriam"
Is there any relevance to him arriving an hour late?
Is Miriam just that he's using his family as emotional leverage to win votes?
I think the being late thing is an illustration of how a ''busy'' member of New Labour would drop everything if necessary when toadying-up to a pop star that they could benefit associating with.
Why ''Miriam''? Dunno...nice, respectable ''middle-class'' name? You could be right about the emotional-card too.
Cocaine Socialism for me. Glory Days has some nice lines in it, but it's a bit vague, to the extent that I didn't really get a sense of what it was about till I heard a bootleg a year or two later where Jarvis explains it's about "spending what are supposedly the best years of your life waiting for a cheque to drop through the door every two weeks" (or something like that).
As an aside, Russell isn't on either released version of Cocaine Socialism. He did record a guitar part for it but it wasn't used, and may even have been wiped.
__________________
"Yes I saw her in the chip shop / so I said get yer top off"
Glory Days is one of their worst songs in my opinion and definitely one of the worst on TIH. That or The Day After the Revolution. Both of them could have been scrapped from the album and replaced with Cocaine Socialism and one of the other TIH b-sides.
__________________
The trees, those useless trees, produce the air that I am breathing
Fred, I think the arriving an hour late is just a way of describing how Jarvis snubbed the invitation.
I think you could be right about Miriam, though I think it's also inferring that the politician was trying to win Jarvis over by showing him respect under false pretences.
I like both songs, though Cocaine Socialism is one of my favourite Pulp songs, mostly due to its really clever lyrics.
Not so much 'snubbing' the invitation but, because he's a cool rock star, he can show up late. And he knows it. And because he's a cool rock star, they tolerate that. In fact, given Tony Blair's seeming love of Rock Stars, they were probably thrilled at the idea that someone would turn up late and snub them a little. They liked a Bad Boy.
Because they understood his situation and his image.
Article from Alex James on the connection that Labour tried to make with Blur:
"When Damon called and said he was going for a G&T with Tony Blair and John Prescott, the then opposition leaders, it didn't strike me as at all unusual. I think what had happened is that the Labour Party market research showed that the people who were buying Blur records were unlikely to vote; but if they did vote, it could be enough to tip the balance in Labour's favour.
We were all invited for drinks at the Commons. It impresses your mother-in-law and it's a pretty good night out. It was nice to give Clare Short a Christmas kiss and Mo Mowlam totally rocked with the best of them. It would have been churlish to reject the opportunity of meeting the people who will run your country, but every time I met a political figure there would be a large-ish piece in the Standard, subtly suggesting an allegiance. Boy, these guys had their shit together. This was expert covert marketing, Nineties style. When I worked out these people weren't my real friends, I returned to the Groucho Club, which was a lot more fun and where, surprisingly, you can make real friends.
By the time the [then] present government was in power, we were sceptical. Damon became a communist when he got a call from Blair's office telling him not to say those things he was saying, if he didn't mind. To see a grinning prime minister shaking hands with a smug-looking Gallagher was politics reduced to pantomime."
Voted for Cocaine Socialism. Love both songs. While I can see how the broadness of Glory Days appeals to some I think I probably prefer the specificity of Cocaine Socialism. And I love the backing vocals at the end. Am I right in saying that's the Swingle Sisters of My Body May Die and Bad Cover Version?
Exactly 50 : 50 atm. Personally I prefer glory days - It may not talk about politics or anything in particular but in my opinion it doesn't need to. Also the lyrics are class
Cocaine Socialism all the way. Glory Days just felt like a dull, gutted approximation. I think even Jarvis seemed to surmise as much;
The songs seem to provide a soundtrack to the '90s. Maybe - I tried to write about things that were going on. I was very aware that, after spending the '80s out of touch, and then suddenly breaking through, it was our time to be involved with the culture of the time, and I wanted to comment on that. The song, "Cocaine Socialism", is a kind of case in point.
It got replaced by "Glory Days" on ...Hardcore. It did. I just copped out really. It was a weird thing. It was probably complete rampant egotism on my part. Because the song was written before Tony Blair got in, and in my rampant egotistic state I thought,'Oh, I don't want to put people off voting Labour - I would like them to, really.' In retrospect, we should have just been bold and put it out, because the way things turned out, it was pretty...