So not even 5 million. Wikipedia claims (based on a dead link) that they had sold over 10 million records by 2002.
I suppose it is remotely possible but unlikely that the non-certified material and non-UK releases would total the near-6 million required to reach the 10 million claim.
I presume that these are based on retail sales because Wikipedia also claims that "Mis-Shapes"/"Sorted For E's and Wizz" had 400,000 pre-release orders. That said, some copies may have been removed from sale due to the sleeve.
So not even 5 million. Wikipedia claims (based on a dead link) that they had sold over 10 million records by 2002.
I suppose it is remotely possible but unlikely that the non-certified material and non-UK releases would total the near-6 million required to reach the 10 million claim.
I presume that these are based on retail sales because Wikipedia also claims that "Mis-Shapes"/"Sorted For E's and Wizz" had 400,000 pre-release orders. That said, some copies may have been removed from sale due to the sleeve.
That's only UK. Also you could get a silver/gold/platinum based on pre-orders from record stores. And never actually sell a copy. I would say pulp easily sold 10 million worldwide, but it would be impossible to verify.
Hits was a grower. Never charted high but was a steady seller over a long period. And I imagine the vinyl will do well when it gets a release.
There's no way Pulp sold 5m records ex-UK. The 10m figure was a lazy upward estimate.
The above are not retail sales, they're trade sales. We Love Life never reached 60k sales nor did Hardcore sell 100k in the UK. We Love Life did 25k in the first week and sadly, bugger-all afterwards. The certs used to be issued based on trade and were expected to translate into people actually buying them.
-- Edited by Eamonn on Friday 21st of November 2025 10:40:41 PM
The above are not retail sales, they're trade sales. We Love Life never reached 60k sales nor did Hardcore sell 100k in the UK. We Love Life did 25k in the first week and sadly, bugger-all afterwards. The certs used to be issued based on trade and were expected to translate into people actually buying them.
Yes. There are numerous LPs that went silver/gold/platinum on release date, but were all in the bargains bins a month later and then sent to be err, pulped. Actual sales are very hard to quantify, but I would say worldwide, Pulp probably did around 10 million. Pulps chart success coincided with the CD age so they probably sold more physical copies than an earlier or later act would have. Robson & Jerome sold nearly 2 million copies of their dirge. So Common People probably wasnt far behind. Just incredibly unlucky not to have been #1.
I'm kind of on the fence with it: the UK is just one relatively small country so if they can sell over 4 million here, it wouldn't be unreasonable to expect that they sold a bit more than that throughout the rest of the world. That said, the UK is where they are most well known. It looks like "Different Class" and "This is Hardcore" reached the top 10 in a few different countries so potentially a million or so copies were sold there.
As for "Hits", back in the day I drove a car with a CD player, I used to buy compilations by bands I only have a passing interest in, often from supermarkets or bargain bins. My logic was that I could either pay less than £5 for an 18 track compilation CD where I know and like the majority of songs or I could pay over £10 for a 12 track album where I know 2 songs then risk not liking the others. Also, they may have pressed plenty of copies of "Hits" in the hope that it would sell more than it actually did. Then there's the fact that it was reissued in a card case at some point. Essentially, it was likely the "go-to" Pulp product for casual fans.
And I never did see the appeal of Robson and Jerome. I don't mind cover versions if they bring something new to a song (see Walker/Brel) but releasing what was essentially a karaoke version of an already fine song just doesn't do it for me.
The point about the certs/awards for units sold is that they were either designated with this status upon release (Hardcore and WLL) due to expectation of wholesale numbers quickly translating into retail - which clearly never happened with those two albums as they've never been certified higher - OR the sales status is updated once each sales milestone is reached, months/years after the album is released.
So you can see in the case of His n Hers, Hits and Different Class, they've passed by the lower milestones and their updated rank (ie quadruple platinum for DC, platinum for Hits) is accurate as its based on people still buying those records years after the release.
I think there's every chance More has already sold more than WLL but it might be that they don't hand out these designations to albums upon release anymore - you have to actually pass the milestones with physical sales first.
-- Edited by Eamonn on Saturday 22nd of November 2025 01:28:03 PM
As for "Hits", back in the day I drove a car with a CD player....
I still do! Full of CDs I get from charity shops, 3 for £1. Only time I used Bluetooth was on a trip from deepest Wales back to London where I had Slade blasting out for the five hour drive. Only thing I was certain wouldn't send me to sleep.
I think Pulp Hits is a pretty good compilation. I never bought it on release, but picked it up a while later when it hit the bargain bins. Aside from the omission of Mis-shapes (no real loss) it is Pulp singles from Razzmatazz to Bad Cover Version which is exact what you want. Maybe not Pulp's greatest but in some ways a better collection than any LP in its own right as it is has Pulp at all their stages. I have always liked good hit compilations. Secret History by The Divine Comedy is an great example of a near perfect compilation that draws you in and makes you seek out other material. Unfortunately, too many are a bit ropey, especially when they have re-recordings of the hits.
And I never did see the appeal of Robson and Jerome. I don't mind cover versions if they bring something new to a song (see Walker/Brel) but releasing what was essentially a karaoke version of an already fine song just doesn't do it for me.
It was all about the TV show. There is a history of great songs denied number ones in UK by novelty acts. Like the Pet Shop Boys making number one ahead of the Pogues
Poor old We Love Life. 5% of the sales of Different Class. Obviously I realised it didn't do as well as the others but not by that far! Maybe they've got a point about not doing a deluxe edition...
Wonder how far behind Intro and the Fire albums are?
__________________
"Yes I saw her in the chip shop / so I said get yer top off"
Poor old We Love Life. 5% of the sales of Different Class. Obviously I realised it didn't do as well as the others but not by that far! Maybe they've got a point about not doing a deluxe edition...
Wonder how far behind Intro and the Fire albums are?
We Love Life was a superb LP, just came out at the wrong time. Wouldn't surprise me if Intro sold more copies. And the Fire LPs have had a few reissues so might not be far behind, especially if you throw in the compilations. It's all irrelevant to me as I bought them all (probably a few too many copies of His n Hers), I pity the fools that didn't
Poor old We Love Life. 5% of the sales of Different Class. Obviously I realised it didn't do as well as the others but not by that far! Maybe they've got a point about not doing a deluxe edition...
Wonder how far behind Intro and the Fire albums are?
We Love Life was a superb LP, just came out at the wrong time. Wouldn't surprise me if Intro sold more copies. And the Fire LPs have had a few reissues so might not be far behind, especially if you throw in the compilations. It's all irrelevant to me as I bought them all (probably a few too many copies of His n Hers), I pity the fools that didn't
Definitely a timing thing. Guitar music was absolutely dead in 2001. The first wave of Britpop were all burnt out. The second wave (Marion, Jocasta, 60ft Dolls, Dandys, Puressence, Laxton's Superb etc.) were all getting dropped, sometimes without even releasing an album. And it was a bit before the third wave (Music, Electric Soft Parade, Elbow, Libertines, Zutons, Bloc Party etc) - that began in 2002. Indie clubs/nights were absolutely deserted at that time.
All that seemed to be doing ok around 2001 was Idlewild and some American bands like Flaming Lips, Mercury Rev and Grandaddy.
-- Edited by HoltbyCity on Monday 24th of November 2025 01:38:53 PM
Poor old We Love Life. 5% of the sales of Different Class. Obviously I realised it didn't do as well as the others but not by that far! Maybe they've got a point about not doing a deluxe edition...
Wonder how far behind Intro and the Fire albums are?
We Love Life was a superb LP, just came out at the wrong time. Wouldn't surprise me if Intro sold more copies. And the Fire LPs have had a few reissues so might not be far behind, especially if you throw in the compilations. It's all irrelevant to me as I bought them all (probably a few too many copies of His n Hers), I pity the fools that didn't
Definitely a timing thing. Guitar music was absolutely dead in 2001. The first wave of Britpop were all burnt out. The second wave (Marion, Jocasta, 60ft Dolls, Dandys, Puressence, Laxton's Superb etc.) were all getting dropped, sometimes without even releasing an album. And it was a bit before the third wave (Music, Electric Soft Parade, Elbow, Libertines, Zutons, Bloc Party etc) - that began in 2002. Indie clubs/nights were absolutely deserved at that time.
All that seemed to be doing ok around 2001 was Idlewild and some American bands like Flaming Lips, Mercury Rev and Grandaddy.
I suspect that had We Love Life came out in early 2004 alongside the likes of the Franz debut LP and Hot Fuss by The Killers it would have been received better. Odd lull at start of 21st century. I blame This is Hardcore
Is This It by The Strokes came out a few weeks before WLL, got a huge amount of attention and credibility (along with The White Stripes), so I'm not sure it's fair to say guitar music was dead at that point.
We Love Life is the sound of a band maturing and settling into early middle-age. It's a wonderful album but commercially very difficult to sell. The nearest to nagging riffs or a hook is probably Minnie Timperley. Weeds has an anthemic quality but nothing like it's massive forebears from '95, Common People and Misshapes.
I think After You could possibly have been tarted-up and been a top twenty hit but that aside, it's kind of slim-pickings.
Is This It by The Strokes came out a few weeks before WLL, got a huge amount of attention and credibility (along with The White Stripes), so I'm not sure it's fair to say guitar music was dead at that point.
We Love Life is the sound of a band maturing and settling into early middle-age. It's a wonderful album but commercially very difficult to sell. The nearest to nagging riffs or a hook is probably Minnie Timperley. Weeds has an anthemic quality but nothing like it's massive forebears from '95, Common People and Misshapes.
I think After You could possibly have been tarted-up and been a top twenty hit but that aside, it's kind of slim-pickings.
In the UK I meant. Everyone here was busy with glow sticks and Paul Oakenfold and Tall Paul and all that awful Trance nonsense. The Stokes definitely kick started the third wave of Britpop - especially the Libertines and Hoggboy (managed by Hawley) being early adopters of a UK take on that new garage rock sound within the following year.
I still do! Full of CDs I get from charity shops, 3 for £1.
Where I live, CDs & DVDs have dropped to 10p in charity shops now. Guess they'll disappear altogether soon - was in one last week with 13 copies of Mamma Mia DVD stacked together - just can't shift the stuff. Pulp Hits is usually in my car for long trips.
I agree WLL suffered from a turn in fashion. And agree that Is This It was the record that started the guitar renaissance, but it was a few years building until The Libertines, et al, made it a fashionable scene again.
For me WLL didn't have catchy singles to grab casual attention on the radio, and not very danceable. That said, of all the Pulp albums it's one that I can really immerse myself in, maybe the most immersive and cohesive as an album, just to really enjoy and get a gentle pleasure from, I come back to it regularly. A mature album, for mature listeners (and now, with More there's the mature stuff, and plenty of silly fun stuff too). TIH is the hardest listen for me; the highpoints are among Pulp's best, but just about the whole b-side is a struggle for me.
For me WLL didn't have catchy singles to grab casual attention on the radio, and not very danceable. That said, of all the Pulp albums it's one that I can really immerse myself in, maybe the most immersive and cohesive as an album, just to really enjoy and get a gentle pleasure from, I come back to it regularly. A mature album, for mature listeners (and now, with More there's the mature stuff, and plenty of silly fun stuff too). TIH is the hardest listen for me; the highpoints are among Pulp's best, but just about the whole b-side is a struggle for me.
I thought Bad Cover Version and Sunrise were pretty good singles and Birds in Your Garden could have been. However, even if Got To Have Love was on WLL it would have got no airplay. No one wanted to play Pulp on the radio and there was a nagging sense the album was the end of Pulp and the start of Jarvis. The album I compare it with from back in the 1980s is XTC's English Settlement where they softened their sound. IMHO the best thing XTC ever did.
Maybe I am strange, but Hardcore is not a hard listen for me. I really enjoy it. Though I do turn off early on the Day After The Revolution. I guess everyone does.
Where I live, CDs & DVDs have dropped to 10p in charity shops now. Guess they'll disappear altogether soon - was in one last week with 13 copies of Mamma Mia DVD stacked together - just can't shift the stuff. Pulp Hits is usually in my car for long trips.
Definitely fewer CDs turfing up at our local charity shop. There is a lot of material I have uploaded on You Tube music that isn't on streaming services. Still love rummaging around looking for obscure gems. Given up on vinyl. £5 for Showaddywaddy's greatest hits???