No idea, I do like these kind of things though. Someone once mentioned a recent -ish U2 tune was quite like an old pulp song- it might be we can dance again, but I'm not to sure, I can't really remember, but they did sound very similar when it was pointed out to me. It might have been even on this forum years ago.
Just listened to Dion's album for the first time, it's called born to be With You, so is the opening track... and listen closely, it's like it's Born To Cry's daddy
The atmosphere, some melody and lyrics are very very... close
And later on the same record, Only You know backing track is pretty much exactly the same as... Don't Let Him Waste Your Time. Never seen the sample credited anywhere.
Jarvis is as guilty as Noel Gallagher
-- Edited by andy on Friday 18th of May 2018 03:25:19 PM
-- Edited by andy on Friday 18th of May 2018 03:27:17 PM
I think it's actually a sample, isn't it? It comes out a bit more when you listen to Glastonbury 1998 recording - Might not be that version but there's definately some backing track going on in there!
Not that it's bad - I really loved that both songs exist and it's kind of nice to work out, as a songwriter, that even your greatest hero just kind of steals stuff and makes it his own!
100%- this is actually a pretty decent tune, never really listened to Leonard Cohen before, just always heard clips of the odd song, but I really enjoyed this
Hmm, more of a Pulp-video vibe. I've heard this song many times over the years, I think I know the bit you're thinking of, the insistent repeated notes on the keys but nah, they wish they could be as good as Pulp.
Yeah, I was trying to add this to Weed's "Sounds Like Pulp" playlist on Spotify last night! David's Last Summer in the breakdown completely. Hawley is a big fan of these and I'm sure Jarvis knew of it too.
I'm sitting here smiling at some of these similarities. I'm loving the original songs too. Great songs. Thanks for the heads up on these. My listening sorted for Saturday night!
You've a good ear for these Ian but your old examples are impossible to check-out as the youtube links are dead :(
Maybe best off typing the name of the song too.
Good idea, I have just attempted to repair this thread the best I can. Dead links have been replaced (apart from one I cannot remember) and artists/titles have been added.
Well, Jarvis and Hawley thought the song sounded like this, didn't they? They got to play Elusive Butterfly with the man himself at a festival a few years ago.
Indeed, the homage is so explicit it's right in the title. But I was still pretty startled when I heard Elusive Butterfly -- artists have been sued on much flimsier grounds, and I'm glad Mr. Lind is not the litigious sort.
I think that the record label would check and credit the original writer on the sleeve / pay royalties if necessary.
"Disco 2000" had the working title of "Gloria" and definitely sounds like it. I'm sure with such a big hit, we would have heard if there were any problems.
I thought a cover version of A Trick Of The Light by Jarvis and Chilly was a pretty surprising thing to hear in a cafe, I realise now from looking in the liner notes that the song actually credits the writer of The Last Tango in Paris theme writer Gato Barbieri as writer of the music but Ive never seen the film and had no idea it wasnt written by ChillyG.
__________________
Please forgive any missing punctuation in the above post, this site seems to make most of mine disappear.
Yes, the original even has some of the mood of Room 29. I watched Last Tango In Paris once, and thought it was pretty horrible. However, I think I was about 13 at the time. Can't remember much, but I think it had a claustrophobic atmosphere, which fits with how some of Room 29 made me feel. Wonderful album, haven't had it out for a year or two, good reminder to put it on again.
Heck, this was probably mentioned years ago, but I must be very dense because I've heard this song however many hundreds of times and only today noticed how much the final 'yeah' (last 5 seconds) reminds me of Pulp.
Spike Island definitely has a whiff of Union City Blue in the main riff. And of course We Can Dance Again lifts the "Your hair is beautiful" line from Atomic.